The forced deportation of Afghan refugees from Pakistan underscores the grim reality faced by displaced populations who find themselves at the mercy of shifting political priorities. For decades, Pakistan has hosted millions of Afghans, many of whom fled conflict, persecution, and economic collapse in their homeland. However, as geopolitical tensions rise and Pakistan enforces stricter immigration policies, these refugees are being pushed into an impossible choice ~ live in fear or return to a country where their safety is far from assured.

The situation is particularly dire for those with past associations with Afghanistan’s former government and security forces. Despite the Taliban’s assurances of a general amnesty, reports continue to surface of targeted killings and persecution. Families that sought refuge in Pakistan after the Taliban takeover in 2021 are now being forced back, with little consideration for the dangers they might face. Many have spent years in Pakistan, building lives, raising children, and contributing to local economies, only to find themselves labeled as illegal migrants and subjected to mass arrests and deportations. Pakistan’s decision to expel undocumented Afghans is not happening in isolation.

Advertisement

It reflects broader regional tensions, particularly concerning cross-border security issues. Pakistan has accused Afghanistan-based militant groups of orchestrating attacks on its soil, leading to a hardening of policies towards Afghan refugees. While national security concerns are legitimate, the indiscriminate crackdown on vulnerable refugees ~ many of whom have no ties to militancy ~ raises serious ethical and humanitarian questions. The plight of these refugees is compounded by the bureaucratic inertia of international organisations and resettlement programmes. Thousands of Afghans who were promised relocation to Western countries remain in limbo, unable to access legal pathways to safety. Reports suggest that even those recognised by international refugee agencies as deserving of protection have not been spared from deportation.

The slow-moving resettlement process has left many stranded, exposing them to arbitrary arrests, poor detention conditions, and forced returns. The broader issue at play here is the lack of a sustainable, humane refugee policy in the region. Pakistan is not a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention, which means it does not formally recognise asylum seekers under international law. Instead, Afghan refugees in Pakistan exist in a legal grey zone ~ permitted to stay for decades yet never granted real security. This policy vacuum has made them vulnerable to shifting political winds, where one moment they are tolerated and the next they are treated as a national burden.

A lasting solution requires a multi-pronged approach. International organisations must expedite the resettlement of vulnerable Afghans, while Pakistan and other host countries should be encouraged to adopt a more compassionate approach to refugees. Afghanistan’s Taliban-led government must also be held accountable for creating conditions that force millions to flee. Until these measures are taken, Afghan refugees will continue to live in fear ~ unwanted in the countries they fled to and unsafe in the land they once called home.